Submit a Question for Neil on Charlie Rose Show Tonight
UPDATE:
The interview has been postponed for later in the week. It will be a full hour.
Neil Young will be appearing on the Charlie Rose
Charlie's website http://www.charlierose.com/home has an area where you can submit questions for Neil. Questions can be e-mailed to charlierose@pbs.org
Here's a few we might hear:
- What's that song "Powderfinger" all about?
- Why did Lynyrd Skynyrd hope that Neil Young will remember that a southern man doesn't need him around anyhow?
So after you submit Neil a question on Charlie's site, come back and drop a comment with your question. Then we can nominate some for consideration!
Thanks Roger!
by thrasher@PermaLink: 7/15/2008 12:28:00 PM
47 comments
>> Pre-Order on Amazon.com << 
Human Highway
Concert Review of the Moment
This Land is My Land
FREEDOM In A New Year
*Thanks Neil!*
![[EFC Blue Ribbon - Free Speech Online]](http://www.thrasherswheat.org/gifs/free-speech.gif)
The Unbearable Lightness of Being Neil Young
Pardon My Heart
"We're The Ones 
Thanks for Supporting Thrasher's Wheat!
This blog 
(... he didn't kill himself either...)
#AaronDidntKillHimself
Neil Young's Moon Songs
Civic Duty Is Not Terrorism
Orwell (and Grandpa) Was Right
What's So Funny About 
47 Comments:
Neil,
What is the color when black is burned?
Curious in Concord
Neil,
Is it hard to make arrangements with yourself
When you're old enough to repay
But young enough to sell?
I have two:
1) RELEASE TIME FADES AWAY PLEEEAASSE!!!!
and,
2)So, do you feel like playing Captain Kennedy sometime?
Oh, come on, not release TFA again!
Please ask some intelligent questions.
For example: About who are you singing in Unknown Legend. Ha, ha, ha.
Neil, what are your musical plans for the near future? Is there another studio album on the cards? Also, any ideas on when the first archives volume will be released?
By the way, the recent gig in Manchester uk was possibly the best i've ever been to!
Is it true that, during the Tonight's The Night tour in 1973, you did not change your clothes, and drank tequila during every show?
That tour is famous for being, arguably, the first punk tour. Will you release any concerts from it in the Archives Performance Series?
How are you enjoying being reunited with Rick Rosas and Chad Cromwell, your rhythm section from The Bluenotes (1988) and The Lost Dogs (1989)? How does this band compare with Crazy Horse, your primary backing band?
Speaking of Crazy Horse, can fans expect The Horse to ride again?
You once said that Sonic Youth's "Expressway To Yr Skull" is the best guitar song you've ever heard. What are some of your other favorite guitar songs?
If the Linc-Volt makes it to Philadelphia, will you let me take a ride?
Here's my question-
"Neil, I understand why you have the current line up for the European tour and the earlier American and European versions of it. But what is your thinking about Crazy Horse these days? I know from personal experience how difficult it can be trying to keep a band somewhat together; your ability to maintain all of your associations for so many years is impressive. So how is the current state of your relationship with the Horse?"
Todd
What's that with 'A day in the life' as an encore during the Euro tour?
(Great to see you cover it and somehow it fits in there too, but...why?)
Neil, I’m a longtime fan of your music career and have been very impressed with your philanthropic efforts through Farm Aid, your work to bring awareness to alternate forms of energy as well as your support over the years for numerous different causes. Those efforts tie in well with a long career singing about a wide range of subject matter that has ranged from deeply personal matters (On The Beach record, Tonight’s The Night record, etc.) to complex love songs (You And Me, Razor Love, etc.) to themes that speak of economic & social injustices (Ohio, Vampire Blues, Rockin’ In The Free World, Depression Blues, This Old House, etc.) to scores of other topics too. You seem to have a great understanding of what’s really going on in this world & express it so well. I hate to bring up money, yet when you hit the road with CSNY—a band closely tied with the counterculture, 60s revolution & what’s supposed to be socially & economically “right” in this beautiful land—the ticket prices are absurdly high. Is it, “Well, the Stones, McCartney, The Eagles, U2, etc. are doing it so why don’t we?” Or, “It doesn’t matter because all the good seats & skyboxes are bought by corporations anyway?” This has confused me ever since you guys got back together in 2000. Even your tour in the Fall 2007 was very, very pricey. On the other hand, since Bruce Springsteen & The E Street Band reformed back in 1999 they have been putting on huge stadium & arena shows all around the U.S. for the past 10 years and their tickets haven’t topped $99. Why is this and do you see why it’s an issue with your middle-class fanbase? You’re a great artist, your music’s alive as ever and you seem like a genuinely good dude. Hopefully you’ll swing through Chicago again soon because I saw you in November at the Chicago Theatre and it was fantastic.
Do you ever see yourself retiring from the music business and maybe whiling away your old age with your model trains and your cars - or can I look forward to another 20 years of your magic and seeing you on stage in your Zimmer frame?
Neil,
I am from Canada and we miss you! Any plans to tour accross this great land of ours?
Alberta *Hint* *Hint*
Hows about a Chronicles book or Documentary to go with Archives? and How about an Album of soungs about Trains?
btw - the natives are gettin restless in Canada alright - frineds of mine over there are well pissed that you're not going home - Dont be denied!!
Say, Thrasher--
Neil is no longer listed on the Charlie Rose site.
So now, when will we see it?
(the real) Chicago
I just checked the digital cable listings, and they say that Neil Young is guest on Charlie Rose tonight, however, there is no mention of him whatsoever on Charlie Rose website. What gives?
Apparently, the interview was so interesting that it's a full hour long and will be aired later this week.
Nice!
Just watched the opening of Charlie Rose. He says the conversation with Neil was so interesting they decided to go the full hour and will air it later this week.
Neil, as you've always been such an informed, astute and learned political commentator, could you tell us where you earned your degree in political science, or, at least how many college credits you have?
Cool, just came back to the office to find out what happened at the Charlie Rose show. Now we get a full hour of Neil... later this week... can't wait
Hey, '7/16/2008 05:49:00 AM Anonymous'
That's got to be one of the most stupid comments I've read in a long time.
So, let me get this straight, by your reckoning no one can voice an opinion on anything they don't have a degree in. Right?
Do you vote? I assume you do. But have you got a degree in all the various fields of expertise that constitute modern government? If not then surely you shouldn't vote, and nor should the vast majority of the population.
Don't get me wrong, I agree it's important for people to have INFORMED opinions – which I think, by in large, Neil has – but to suggest you need degrees in all areas you voice an opinion about is, quite frankly, ridiculous.
Neil,
How about MirrorBall 2!
-Adam
No, my point was that Neil's is incredibly uninformed about nearly everything he talks about. I have a PhD in International Studies from Columbia University. Anytime that you or the well-informed Neil would care to debate, let me know.
At 7/16/2008 08:00:00 AM, Anonymous said...
Hey, '7/16/2008 05:49:00 AM Anonymous'
That's got to be one of the most stupid comments I've read in a long time.
So, let me get this straight, by your reckoning no one can voice an opinion on anything they don't have a degree in. Right?
Do you vote? I assume you do. But have you got a degree in all the various fields of expertise that constitute modern government? If not then surely you shouldn't vote, and nor should the vast majority of the population.
Don't get me wrong, I agree it's important for people to have INFORMED opinions – which I think, by in large, Neil has – but to suggest you need degrees in all areas you voice an opinion about is, quite frankly, ridiculous.
I sent in: "at what point in the day do you tell the band the set list for the night's show?"
Sandy, Lake of Bays
That's an interesting question Sandy! Highlights of NY shows for me are always the gaps in between songs. The fine moments nobody in the band nows which song will be played next. Just because NY changed his mind during the set.
Good for you, I'm glad you have a PhD in International Studies from Columbia University. Well done.
I have a BTEC diploma in Graphic Design from Suffolk College myself.
My point stands. Does the fact that someone has not studied a subject at degree level preclude them from voicing an opinion on said subject, as long as that opinion is reasonably well informed?
I understand your point that you don't think that Neil is informed enough. Fair enough, that's your PhD opinion. My problem is your suggestion that unless you have studied to a certain level in said subject, your opinion is some how worthless. I'm sure there are many things that you have strong opinions about that you have not studied at degree level.
Let's see... Global warming. Do you have an opinion? Or does the fact that you don't have a PhD in climate studies preclude you from having an opinion?
At Anonymous 7/16/2008 11:52:00 AM
No, my point was that Neil's is incredibly uninformed about nearly everything he talks about. I have a PhD in International Studies from Columbia University. Anytime that you or the well-informed Neil would care to debate, let me know.
When will you come to Slovenia?
Neil,
I have listened to "Flags Of Freedom" from Living With War
several times today and I'm blown away by the picture you paint in this song. I have no ties to the military, but feel like you have created an image right out of Mayberry {Andy would be proud}.
The lyrics ...
"Have you seen the flags of freedom
What color are they now?
Do you think that you believe in yours
More than they do theirs somehow?"
... leave me speechless.
I've been a fan for 40 years - can't wait for Archives.
Charlie Rose: Neil, in CSNY Graham was the "quiet one", Stephen was the "smart one", and David was the "cute one". Which one were you?
Neil: The one who got out while the gettin' was good.
Charlie Rose: Innarestin!
Just thought this might be of interest with some of the questions I've seen....I got a note from someone on the "inside" that it is very likely Neil will be making his way through some Canadian Dates in the Fall...and this is a reliable source. So more dates coming!!
It's too late, but:
Neil,
Given your current opposition to the Iraq War, do you now regret having recorded "Let's Role" after 9/11?
"Let's roll for freedom,
Let's roll for love,
We're going after Satan,
On the wings of a dove."
Or were these lyrics supposed to be ironic? (If so, many people missed the irony and thought you were advocating some kind of punative war. You knew this from the belacose cheering that greeted the song at live concerts.)
It's great that you opposed the Iraq occupation on Living with War in 2006, but a rational voice for peace back in 2001 might have done more good.
So, do you feel in any way responsable for helping Dick Cheney and Don Rumsfeld sell the American people on the idea of an invasion? Or does an artist have no responsiblity for how his message is interpreted?
The wanker who said "could you tell us where you earned your degree in political science, or, at least how many college credits you have?" is a tit head. Neil Young also doesn't have a degree in economics or even an MBA, yet he has amassed a tremendous personal fortune. How can that be? It shouldn't have happened; he's not...qualified...!
Tom
Re: "Let's Roll".... Todd Beamer said "let's roll" to his wife on his cell phone prior to hanging up and trying to save Flight 93 in Pennsylvania. Listen to any interview Neil did around the release of 'Are You Passionate?' (or the lyrics of the song). It's about Todd's heroism.
I must admit that I like "Last Child" by Aerosmith slightly better. ;)
Hi, Neil two questions do you own a 59 caddy? and question # 2 how come all song on a six string banjo are played in G Thanks for the bridge school Larry cherry Hill N.J.
To the idiot that wrote "could you tell us where you earned your degree in political science, or, at least how many college credits you have?"
What a ridiculous comment, you are clearly not a Neil Young fan, why post such a stupid thing on here. Go away now please.
According to the Charlie Rose website, Neil is scheduled to appear tonight (Thursday).
This should be great!!!!!!
Marian M.
what does he feel his greatest achievement here on Earth has been so far beyond the family, fame, etc ... what has he learned about his own humanity?
What's on his bucket list?
#! Does he have a bucket list and what is on his bucket list?
#2. Beside his career, family, and fame, what has been his greatest achievement as a human being?
Briefs or boxers?
Just kidding!
Chicago
Formal education is a system of imposed ignorance.
Has either living beatle commeted on your cover of Day in the Life?
What has been you favourite venue of this cuurent tour
Lastly of the bands knocking around at the moment you are you listening to and who are climbing the right ladder
Neil,
Does the fact that there are an incredible amount of Moe-Rons on a Thrashers Wheat, that track your every fart annoy you?
Do you think that the fact that they live vicariously threw you
is a sickness?
Since you are an advocate of Freedom of Speech, is it wrong of Thrasher to delete this posting?
Curious Minds want to know!
Chili
Has Chili nowhere to go to this morning except here? Of all the places you can you be this morning, you came here to do what? Draw attention to yourself by letting off some of your own gas? Spreading a little bit of your own sickness?
He doesn't get it that bowl full of Chili, does he? Neil's attitude and drive to find a solution has done more than add a new light in our world. It has magically connected us to all sorts of opportunities that were somehow absent before he came along.
Only connect...
Mr. Young
I don't know much about you and your music. However after watching Charlie Rose Show, I realized that we are somehow connected.
I wish to introduce you my master.
She is a little lady but big. I truly think you two will get along well. Why don't you find out yourself. Please visit: www.suprememastertv.com/ or www.godsdirectcontact.org
I only wish you would my massage.
God or Ala or Buddha or anything you believe in be with you and guide you.
why connect if you're already plugged in?
As far as being an "expert" =
Neil didn't have much of a
musical education, either
He seems to know what he's doing, however
The best interview with Neil I've ever seen, and I've witnessed plenty.
Neil was lucid,open and revelatory. Those who have criticized him for being aloof and disconnected should heed his call for unity. He is a "uniter", not a partisan.
Our "leaders" should be so passionate.
May "THE SPIRIT" continue to guide him...
Post a Comment
<< Home