A GREAT QUESTIONNeil Young Archives | Letters to Editor
(Click photo to enlarge)Neil Young's vinyl releases have long been -- paradoxically -- a source of great joy and frustration.
Finally, it seems that someone has gotten Neil's attention on the long running issue of vinyl quality, decisions and pricing.
Over on
Neil Young Archives | Letters to Editor , Peter in Dublin writes a thoughtful and provocative letter which NYA headlines as "A GREAT QUESTION". Read the letter in full for all the specific details. To summarize very briefly this complex, multi-faceted subject, the vinyl frustrations have peaked around releases with "etching sides", i.e., no music. For example,
Tuscaloosa album on 2 LPs, but on 3 sides, but now with Bonus Tracks released on NYA that could have gone on Side 4 instead of an etching of the Crazy Horse logo.
Another example given is the Toast album, totaling only 51 minutes on 2 LPs, again on only 3 sides, with Side 4 an etching of the Crazy Horse logo.
Peter in Dublin goes on to cite numerous other Neil Young's vinyl releases which fall short of fan expectations of vinyl quality and value.
Neil responds with:
"What a great refreshing letter!!!!"
Neil goes on to reply that he plans to review the letter with Engineers John Hanlon, Niko Bolas and others to "come up with answers".
Thanks to Peter in Dublin for asking the uncomfortable questions.
Labels: albums, neil young, vinyl
1 Comments:
Fully agree with the sentiment of the question. It has also irked me. The related question is why many of the discs in archives box sets end up being released individually on vinyl. If I knew with confidence I could get all the same music on a nice stack of vinyl, I'd skip the boxes of CDs/Blu-rays, but once I've purchased the boxes, I'm not keen to spend more to get the vinyl (my preferred format).
Post a Comment
<< Home