An unofficial news blog for Neil Young fans from Thrasher's Wheat with concert and album updates, reviews, analysis, and other Rock & Roll ramblings. Separating the wheat from the chaff since 1996.
Pages
▼
Wednesday, July 07, 2021
Splendid Isolation: Neil Young's Vocals Isolated on 'Heart of Gold' | Far Out Magazine
Neil Young: In the 1970's
A rather interesting experiment involving Neil Young's oh-so classic and beloved song 'Heart of Gold'.
If one song sealed Neil Young’s transformation from counter-culture
stalwart to a new rock and roll poster boy, then it has to be ‘Heart of
Gold’.
Another brilliant song from the Harvest album, which could have
easily dominated this list, sees Young transcend rock and roll and turn
pop, if only for a short while.
Featuring backing vocals from none
other than James Taylor and Linda Ronstadt, the song shot Young into
stardom and was later despised by the songwriter. It’s a song that,
ironically, Bob Dylan saw as purposely copying him: “The only time it
bothered me that someone sounded like me was when I was living in
Phoenix, Arizona, in about ’72 and the big song at the time was ‘Heart
of Gold’,” he once commented.
From performance in 1971 on the BBC, here is Neil Young's song 'Heart of Gold' with his vocals isolated. Listen.
I'm not sure if "sounded like me" is the same as "copying" someone? I am also not sure that Neil ever "despised" the song? I think it is all a bit more complicated.
I am sorry. First of all, I did not mean to come across as derogatory, like it is a bad article or something. I know that it was Dylan who said those things- that he Dylan- said the stuff about how it sounded like him or something quite similar. My point was that I don't think Dylan seems right about this? Perhaps I am musically naive, but Heart of Gold seems to me to be not like Dylan at all? It has a simplicity, etc.... Apologies for any misunderstanding.
Ya, Dylan never played a harmonica that sounded as sweet as Neil’s on that song. Neil is a more impressive harp player. I remain a big Dylan fan, but Neil has made a lot more music with honey-sliders in it…. I mean honey on the harp. 😂 Alan in Seattle
I kinda think this isolation technology makes Neil sound almost as horrible as Dylan. What's the point anyway? It's not like his voice is ever hard to hear on his records. I don't get it.
*CLICK ON ABOVE LINK & SCROLL DOWN TO COMMENT BOX* Please observe Comments Policy for Neil Young News. All commenting requires a registered ID using an OpenID or a Google Account to provide a validated signature.
Inappropriate comments can be flagged for review by e-mailing date/time stamp and post title to: thrasher@thrasherswheat.org
We will work to deal with such comments in a timely fashion. Failure to do so immediately, however, does not constitute endorsement.
Thank you for your participation, cooperation, and keep on rockin'!
I'm not sure if "sounded like me" is the same as "copying" someone? I am also not sure that Neil ever "despised" the song? I think it is all a bit more complicated.
ReplyDeletehmm. right Abner. It is complicated.
ReplyDeleteBut the way we read the Far Out article linked, was that it was Dylan who said the items you quoted?
maybe something has been lost in translation here?
I am sorry. First of all, I did not mean to come across as derogatory, like it is a bad article or something. I know that it was Dylan who said those things- that he Dylan- said the stuff about how it sounded like him or something quite similar. My point was that I don't think Dylan seems right about this? Perhaps I am musically naive, but Heart of Gold seems to me to be not like Dylan at all? It has a simplicity, etc.... Apologies for any misunderstanding.
ReplyDeleteAgreed. Not like Dylan. Dylan was being Dylan-centric. It’s not ALL about Dylan.
Deleteno worries, of course Abner.
ReplyDeleteyes, it always did seem strange. also, this was back in the 70's. so who knows what really happened.
obviously, today there is great respect between Bob & neil ... just as it should be.
Right agreed, as it should be!
ReplyDeleteLove some Splendid Isolation... but hope we're coming out on the other side!
ReplyDeleteGood singing!
ReplyDeleteBob’s subtle way of complimenting Neil’s harmonica skills…
ReplyDeleteThe comment so nice it had to be made twice!
ReplyDeleteYa, Dylan never played a harmonica that sounded as sweet as Neil’s on that song. Neil is a more impressive harp player. I remain a big Dylan fan, but Neil has made a lot more music with honey-sliders in it…. I mean honey on the harp. 😂 Alan in Seattle
DeleteI kinda think this isolation technology makes Neil sound almost as horrible as Dylan. What's the point anyway? It's not like his voice is ever hard to hear on his records. I don't get it.
ReplyDelete